LOST Store: Shirts, hats, stickers, buttons, and more!

Tuesday, March 06, 2007

"Tricia Tanaka is Dead" Notes, Assorted Theories, and "Enter 77" Spoilers

[Listen to this episode!] [Subscribe to the MP3 feed via iTunes]

In "Tricia Tanaka is Dead," Hurley finds a Volkswagen bus with a DHARMA logo on the front, tipped on its side in the middle of the jungle. In the vehicle is the dessicated corpse of a man, apparently named Roger, who was a "workman" in the DHARMA Initiative. It is not clear how Roger died or how the car got tipped on its side (although both of these questions may correlate with all the alcohol in the vehicle). It also seems rather strange that Roger's coworkers never came to look for him—he was apparently a DHARMA employee, driving a DHARMA vehicle. Inside the van is a map that appears to detail a road leading from the Swan station to some other part of the island. It would appear that the road passes through a mountain range.

Hurley is determined to get the vehicle running. Based on my (admittedly very limited) knowledge of how cars work, I was extremely doubtful about whether it was possible for the car to run after having laid on its side in the jungle for several years. In hindsight, I'm surprised that none of the four men thought about the possibility that fluids would have leaked out of the car or at least degraded over time. According to Jared on this week's Black Rock Podcast, there should have been no way that the car could have run. While many people saw this episode as very light on mysterious elements, I see this as a definite mystery of the island. Hurley being able to put his faith in the car starting, and then it actually happening against all probability, seems to strongly counteract the theme of hopelessness from the recent Desmond episode. Whereas Desmond was told that he could not ultimately change the course of the universe, and he believed that Charlie was doomed to die "no matter what I try to do," now it seems as though Hurley may have broken the curse of the numbers through his faith. Based on everything we've seen in Hurley's post-lottery flashbacks—and based on logic—the car probably should have crashed and Charlie probably should have died, but the car started miraculously at precisely the right moment.

Kate thinks she needs to save Jack, even though Jack explicitly told her not to come back for him. Perhaps part of the reason Jack said this was because he hoped he'd still have his ticket off the island after saving Ben's life, but certainly another reason is that Jack didn't want anyone risking their own lives to save him. It's interesting how Jack seems to feel the most fulfilled when he's saving other people's lives—or at least that seems to be when he feels he's living up to his potential. Jack set himself up as a martyr, putting his own life on the line to save Kate and Sawyer, and then he did the same for Juliet.

Here are a few theories not specifically related to "Tricia Tanaka is Dead" that I've been considering lately. A reader suggested the possibility that Karl was lying about never having heard of The Brady Bunch, but I believe that Karl was telling the truth and had honestly never heard of it. Why? Because I think that Karl has lived on the island his whole life, like Ben.

The question could be asked, if Ethan was The Other's surgeon, and Ben already knew before the crash that he had a tumor, why would he send his only surgeon into a dangerous situation? If fan theories based on Episode 1 of Season 3 are correct, and Ethan and Juliet had or were developing a relationship, it wouldn't be surprising if Ben was jealous about it since we know from Tom that Ben and Juliet have "got history." Perhaps Ben intentionally put Ethan in harm's way to spite Juliet, or perhaps he did it so he could be with her, similar to the story of what David did to Uriah in the Old Testament (see 2 Samuel 11).

A caller to both the Lost Community Podcast and Jay and Jack's podcast pointed out that the symbol on Cadbury creme egg candies is almost identical to the mark that was branded onto Juliet's back—an eight-pointed star with one ray longer than the rest. Since Cadbury creme eggs are most often sold around Easter, this symbol might have been an "Easter egg" joke by the writers.

For those who will be tuning out to avoid spoilers, don't forget to add me on MySpace and take my short podcast listener survey!

The remainder of this post contains spoilers.

The official ABC synopsis for this week's Sayid-centric episode, "Enter 77," is as follows:
Locke, Sayid and Kate investigate a strange structure and its mysterious inhabitant. Meanwhile, Sawyer competes in a ping-pong competition to get back his belongings.
The "strange structure" may be the Flame Station, which we're supposed to see for the first time this season. The "mysterious inhabitant" is the guy fans have been calling "Patchy," the guy with the eyepatch that Nikki and the gang saw on the monitor in the Pearl Station. We'll see Ms. Klugh again for the first time this season, and we'll also see the return of Dr. Marvin Candle (it will be interesting to see if he has yet another name in this episode). Other guest appearances include Danielle Rousseau, Paulo, and Nikki.

An audio clip from this week's Official LOST Podcast reveals that the "strange structure" (which Kate calls a "house") has a very large satellite dish that Sayid believes can transmit thousands of miles, and Danielle says that she's never been there before. Sayid decides to enter unarmed, and Danielle keeps her distance, believing that some of those who enter the building may not come out alive.

Labels: , , ,


Blogger MasterNak said...

Since this blog post talked about some "assorted theories," I decided I would give more thoughts I had on the Desmond time travel issue.

I really don't think they should have brought the whole time travel
issue into Lost at all, period. It's a can of worms that leads to all sorts of debate, which I think will ultimately take away from the show rather than add to it.

In my opinion, pretty much everything that has been in Lost so far - although unbelievable - has still been PLAUSIBLE. Time travel, at least at this present time, just flat out is not possible. I
haven't done in-depth research or anything, but looking at the links
from tJM's "Flashes Before Your Eyes" Initial Thoughts post, it seems like a huge stretch to explain how Desmond went back in time.

About black holes: Kip Thorne thinks that matter wouldn't even be able to make it to the point of singularity (which, in a Kerr hole, from my understanding of it, would be the point where it links to the white hole, allowing time travel). You would be destroyed before you could even make it to the white hole.

About wormholes: Hawking makes the observation that "a time machine
will be built someday, but has not yet been built, so the tourists from the future cannot reach this far back in time." (In other words - again, from my limited understanding - a wormhole could only take you back to the point at which it was created. I guess you could say the end of a wormhole somehow existed in Desmond's apartment in 1996... but I don't know. Still seems like a big stretch. Also - even if you do
say that the end of the wormhole was in Desmond's apartment - this
would not explain how he went back to the future. Wouldn't he have to
return to the site of the wormhole to go back to the future? And it
gets even worse if you say there was a SECOND wormhole in the bar... it just gets incredibly messy to try to explain.)

In addition, I started thinking about the whole "Back to the Future" time travel aspect - How did the Desmond from the future and the Desmond from the past "collide"? Obviously, we didn't see a "past Desmond" and a "future Desmond" running around (as in the B to the F films). In fact, it doesn't even seem like the past Desmond disappeared when the
future Desmond showed up - it looks more like, if anything, future
Desmond's consciousness entered past Desmond's body, or something along those lines. Penny looked more concerned about Desmond than surprised by finding him in painter's clothes on the floor covered in paint. It seems like past Desmond was in the middle of painting when future Desmond entered his body. In all of the stories about time travel, I
have never heard of anything along these lines - where the future
person's CONSCIOUSNESS entered the past person's body.

All of this is to say that the writers should have done more research on time travel before incorporating it into the show - or just not touched the subject at all.

Wednesday, March 07, 2007 4:17:00 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home